Tracing Links Between Fracking and Earthquakes
In society’s ever-deeper dig for energy, one of the risks is causing the Earth to move.
The most recent dramatic example came on New Year’s Eve outside of Youngstown, Ohio. A 4.0 earthquake was the last and largest of a series of temblors that prompted state officials to halt nearby underground disposal of wastewater from hydraulic fracturing for natural gas. There were no reports of serious damage or injury, but the impact in the energy world could be significant.
In the past two years, there have been three other cases in the United States and one in England (see map) where regulators or scientists traced links between seismic activity and fracking, or the disposal of briny and polluted fracking wastewater through underground injection. Ohio Department of Natural Resources Director Jim Zehringer took pains during a news conference to emphasize that the seismic events near Youngstown were “not a direct result of fracking,” but of the wastewater disposal.
But since fracking for natural gas requires about 4 million gallons (15 million liters) of water, a large volume of which will return to the surface at well completion (with more coming up over the life of the well), dealing with its disposal is a fairly important indirect result.
(Related interactive: “Breaking Fuel From Rock With Water“)
And in the case of quakes in Garvin County, Oklahoma and Lancashire, England, it is the fracking itself that is suspected of stimulating seismic activity.
The new wave of natural gas drilling with high-volume hydraulic fracturing is not the first or only energy development that has been linked to seismic activity. The most damaging earthquake in Australia’s history, in 1989, has been linked to the cumulative impact of 200 years of coal mining. University of Utah scientists have been researching the connection between coal mining and earthquake patterns in the Wasatch Plateau and the Book Cliffs.
But fracking is part of a new wave of energy development that involves injecting fluid underground under pressure. Fluid injection is also used in “enhanced oil recovery,” to force oil out of wells once thought to be too depleted for further development. And the technique is not limited to fossil fuel development. One of the high-potential renewable energy technologies–enhanced geothermal energy–requires stimulation of hot rock underground by water. A major geothermal project in Basel, Switzerland was shut down in 2006 after it generated earthquakes. There are also seismic concerns over one of the technologies that is a hope for addressing global warming: Carbon dioxide sequestration underground.
In a project that has been proceeding over the past year mostly under the radar, the U.S. National Academies of Science is expected to publish a study this spring on induced seismicity and energy technologies. “A potentially adverse side effect of subsurface fluid injection in all of these technologies is induced seismicity,” the NAS says. The study is clearly just a first step; it aims to identify what further research needs to be done to give policy makers information they need to develop safety guidelines on this new wave of energy projects.
Related Topics
Go Further
Animals
- Cougar travels 1,000 miles in one of longest recorded treksCougar travels 1,000 miles in one of longest recorded treks
- Rare gray whale spotted in the Atlantic—and it's only the beginningRare gray whale spotted in the Atlantic—and it's only the beginning
- Why 'funga' is just as important as flora and faunaWhy 'funga' is just as important as flora and fauna
- Termite fossils prove mating hasn't changed in 38 million yearsTermite fossils prove mating hasn't changed in 38 million years
Environment
- Why the 2024 hurricane season could be especially activeWhy the 2024 hurricane season could be especially active
- Mushroom leather? The future of fashion is closer than you think.Mushroom leather? The future of fashion is closer than you think.
- This deadly fungus is hitchhiking its way across the worldThis deadly fungus is hitchhiking its way across the world
- Why 'funga' is just as important as flora and faunaWhy 'funga' is just as important as flora and fauna
- This exploding mine holds a treasure that may change the worldThis exploding mine holds a treasure that may change the world
History & Culture
- See the story of Jonah and the whale like never beforeSee the story of Jonah and the whale like never before
- This ancient mosaic offers extraordinary insights into the pastThis ancient mosaic offers extraordinary insights into the past
- These are the real dunes that inspired Dune—and you can visit themThese are the real dunes that inspired Dune—and you can visit them
- Meet the only woman privy to the plot to kill Julius CaesarMeet the only woman privy to the plot to kill Julius Caesar
Science
- Women’s bodies are understudied—but that’s starting to changeWomen’s bodies are understudied—but that’s starting to change
- Hundreds of tiny arachnids are likely on your face right nowHundreds of tiny arachnids are likely on your face right now
- What's worse than a hangover? Hangxiety. Here's why it happens.What's worse than a hangover? Hangxiety. Here's why it happens.
Travel
- A taste of West Bengal, from curries to Kolkata street foodA taste of West Bengal, from curries to Kolkata street food
- Discover southeastern Spain's secret coastal regionDiscover southeastern Spain's secret coastal region
- All aboard Norway's slow train under the midnight sunAll aboard Norway's slow train under the midnight sun